Design & Decor

4 Differences Between Shingles and Tiles Roofing

Story Highlights
  • Material
  • Aesthetics
  • Durability
  • Environmental Impact

Whether you’re building a new home or renovating the current one, the most crucial aspect is roofing.

You must get the right material for your roof. Trying to skimp there will only bite you back in the rear side later. Period.

Any homeowner can agree that installing a roof is a serious investment and definitely not taken lightly.

To avoid future issues with the roofing, you should make sure to do some research and get expert advice beforehand about the installation process. The materials that you picked could help to get a nice and robust roof, while considering that you need to get complete roof maintenance every 25 years.

Tiles and shingles are the most popular choices in roofing, whereby both have their advantages and disadvantages.

We listed four quick differences between shingles and tiles to help you choose the best roofing for your home:


Asphalt type’s shingles are most commonly in use today.

There are two base materials used in asphalt shingles: organic and fibreglass. Asphalt covers base materials from both or one side. The exposed surface of asphalt shingle incorporates quartz, schist, brick, and slate. The underside of the shingle includes the treatment of mica, talc, or sand.

Organic shingles include wood fibre, cellulose, or paper. Fibreglass shingles comprise reinforced glass fibres bonded with urea-formaldehyde resin. In both types, the base material covered in a saturated asphalt base on the exposed side and granules of sand or mica on the underside.

And hence asphalt shingles are waterproof and have excellent heat-reflecting properties. It can withstand wind and hail damage and is resistant to fire and algae.

Roof tiles are present in our history for thousands of years. Tiles are traditionally made from terracotta and slate, whereas modern materials such as concrete and plastic are widely used in roof tiles nowadays.

Modifications on tiles – using different materials like stone and metal. The types of tiles are composite, stone coated metal, terracotta, and concrete. They are much heavy. They would need a separate underlayment of wood and flashing.

Keep in mind that, originally, tile roofs were designed to keep the rainwater out. They have well resistant against fire, hail, and wind damages. Nowadays, solar tiles are very popular – they consist of photovoltaic cells to generate renewable energy.


The aesthetic look of the tiles is also critical.

You, as a homeowner, are investing time and money on your roof, so that said, the roof should look beautiful, wouldn’t you agree?

Both shingles and tiles have their aesthetic appeal. It would be best if you inquired about your roofing contractor about the forever roofing style you need for the roof.

Overlapped shingles on each other can give an appearance of the slate. They have a variety of texture and material, which may appear flat. They are available in various ranges of styles and colors. So you can choose your pick from it.

Tiles have much versatility in design. You can choose from arrays of patterns, design, and style for your roof. The most common style used is Spanish-tile.

In the end, you, as a homeowner, can pretty much decide what kind of appearance you want for your roof.


It shouldn’t be too big of a surprise that the durability of any roofing material depends on its maintenance.

Homeowners should do thorough research on roof maintenance. A few tips on maintenance include–lookout for moss or algae growth. Clean them gently. Avoid using the pressure washer of any roofing. On-time replacement of any broken shingles or tiles.

Life for asphalt shingles roofing is between 15 to 30 years and will depend on the thickness, style, and type of shingle you choose.

Life of tile roofing is between 25 to 100 years. Again, that’ll depend on how well the maintenance and caring is. There are some clay tiles roofs above 100 years. Overall, metal and composite types tend to last longer than regular tiles.  

Environmental Impact

It is very crucial to know the environmental repercussions of any actions we take and the same goes for roofing material.

Asphalt shingles cannot be recycled. Did you know that the Environmental Protection Agency states that the United States generates approximately 11 million of asphalt shingle waste? And don’t get us started on the tedious disposal methods.

However, asphalt shingle roofing has an environmental benefit that is heat-reflecting shingles can lower the energy costs by reducing the temperature of the house.

On the other hand, tile shingles are recyclable. The waste of clay tiles can end up in a landfill without any soil pollution. The composite type materials can also be recycled, making tile roofing an excellent eco-friendly choice.

There are pros and cons for both shingles and tiles roofing. You, as a homeowner, should decide what is best for your dream house.

However, it is essential to keep in mind that you know what kind of roof is ideally suitable for your region and its climatic conditions.

For example, asphalt shingles can withstand most of the weather conditions. Tiles are ideal for cold temperature regions. Always get the opinion of the experts.

Bottom line: a good roof could add quite some value to your home, whereby one can view it more as an investment than a cost to install a decent roof.

Ross Geller Is an Interior Decorator and a passionate writer who loves to write about creating an aesthetic and ambient living environment for everyone. He focuses on sharing ideas and techniques learned from his experience as an Interior Decorator in a concise manner so that it can be used by everyone to make their surroundings beautiful to live in. Currently, he’s working with the Best Roofing Company.


South Africa's No.1 FREE-TO-LIST Estate Agent Property Portal. A hub of info covering topics for #homebuyers, #homesellers, #renters and #lifestyle enthusiasts!

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button